I’m in strong agreement with most of your thoughts about the T1 across this thread although I do think it has a place for starting songs at times. I quite enjoyed a few of the demos where they start a jam and then variation and complexity evolves into the pattern (if that makes sense!!!) works quite well for me as a compositional form. I wouldn’t want to start every song like that but I can see the appeal for that specifically at times.
I’d been pretty satisfied for a long, long time with Elektron boxes and the computer thinking that I was well covered for sequencing but more recently (thanks to other threads here…) I’ve started getting more interested in sequencing as a more deeply performable aspect… getting beyond muting tracks, switching patterns etc. I’ve ordered a Toraiz Squid which should hopefully arrive next week and I’m looking forward to trying ideas where I’m combining that with onboard Elektron sequences. So, I’m definitely seeing the T1 as being interesting for expanding on and exploring those ideas.
I don’t think the price is outrageously high but it’s not cheap enhough that I could justify it on a whim. I certainly should be getting to know other things more before adding to the pile but there is always the outside chance of an early backer perk that tempts me.
Sure, your comparison is concrete but it’s also a comparison that could be applied in so many circumstances that it seems weird (to me at least) that you’re so specifically fixated about the T1 being so replicable by an iPad. It would be an equally easy argument to make that the $20 iOS app is an extravagent spend when I could replicate it to some other arbitrary extent using stuff I already have in my computer?
Ultimately, I guess, everyone consider a thing as a whole and how it fits into their needs, preferences and circumstances.