4-week update: the main point is that I’ve never been more productive. I think the honeymoon is over, and I’m still having so much fun with it. I’ve produced a ton of short beats/ideas, some are bad, others are at least promising. Then I’ve turned a few good ones into things I’m kind of proud of, about 4 “songs” (still just in the form of an 8-16 bar sequence that I perform live with track mutes, filter envelopes and pad mutes to turn it into an evolving song structure). And then I’ve finalized one full song along with all the little automations recorded onto a full song sequence.
So that’s my quantitative output in just a month: about 5 songs and several scrapped ideas. Before that, I spent the last 2-3 months on the Digitone, where I made 3 song embryos similar to the MPC live performance songs above. All of them I’m proud of, the Digitone sounds so great! And before that, I spent the last 6 months producing merely 2 complete songs in Reason 10.
So:
- Reason: 0.33 songs per month
- Digitone: 1 song per month
- MPC: 5 songs per month
Why is that even relevant? Fair question. It’s maybe not. But it’s indicative of how fun the experience is and also how productive it is. Also, practice makes perfect. I now hear song ideas in my head again, in ways I did 25 years ago when I was 17 years old.
For me, the main conclusion here is that hardware makes me much more productive as a musician in general, and the MPC in particular is the sweet spot between performance-friendly synth hardware and song arrangement/groovebox capabilities. What the MPC has done for me is to really turn music making into a daily activity. I have it mostly on the table in the living room, and I occasionally plug in the Keystep 37 using the USB cable, and it’s such a simple, self-contained setup. I sit down a few minutes here and there throughout the day, and then I spend some evenings in more focused 2-hour sessions. I never get stuck in an endless 2am session like I did in Reason every time. It’s more quick, fun, and immediate. If I don’t like a beat, I move on. If I like it, I quickly lay down some more layers, like pad chords, bass, or whichever is needed. Making music on the MPC doesn’t feel like a project, it feels like a “no pressure” side activity.
I’m still learning new things about it. In the 2.10 update, they introduced this completely hidden feature of 8 effects laid out right there on each pad on a drum kit. They’re amazing! You can easily add some distortion, bitcrushing, EQ, etc on each pad individually, just as easily as you can change pitch, loop mode, or anything else on a sample. It’s almost as immediate as the Digitakt (though not quite as versatile and creatively surprising, maybe).
I keep comparing against the Digitakt and Digitone because they were my gateway drug into hardware, and I’m still not sure what to do with them. They are no doubt unique, especially the Digitone. It’s such a beast of creativity with its ability to affect all tracks at once on synth parameters like the filter envelope, that’s just a level of creativity that the MPC does not have. The Digitakt feels much more barebones to me, it’s really just a basic sampler with the amazing Elektron sequencer workflow, but I don’t feel I need that and the MPC. But I could see myself holding on to the Digitone just based on how great it sounds. But I’m getting off topic here.
Maybe a short line about my music: I’d probably call it trance, or maybe just “electronic music”, not limited to just 130 bpm tracks but exploring some other slower tempos too. Very synth heavy, about the only samples I use are drums. I’m probably not the ideal MPC user because I’m about as far away from boom bap music as you could come. 
Anyway, the bottom line is: for me at least, the MPC One has made me a more productive musician than I’ve ever been before.