Bonus: explain your choices 
I have done just this!
Well, perhaps not “from scratch” as I’ve owned the monitors for ages.
Drumatix (808+606, what’s not to like?)
TT-606 (great sequencer)
DR-110 (classic, affordable, variation on the 606 sound I love)
Digitone (infinite depth)
Monologue (creative sequencer bc parameters and notes are independently mutable)
Octatrack MKII (infinite depth)
Analog Drive + other pedals (for grit)
27" quad iMac w/ Live 9 and some VSTs (gotta record and mix with something!)
MOTU Ultralite MK4 + 8 channel a/d (ultra low latency, plenty of inputs, excellent A/D-D/A)
Genelec 8030a (effortless to mix on)
KRK 10" SUB (boom!)
There’s not a sound I can’t make (or sample
) and I find it ideal for the music I make.
.
And under $8k
Assuming I already have an iMac:
- Neumann KH310A 3000 (best monitors under 5K)
- Focusrite 18i20 500 ish (decent enough, better costs too much)
- Elektron Digitakt & Digitone 1000 (bang and sound quality for buck)
- The remaining 5500 on Eurorack. Mainly Intellijel, Make Noise and Erica Synths (Eurorack is the best way and most fun way to make your own sounds in my opinion)
$10K AUD? Doesnt go far
MONO SYNTH
MOOG SUB 37 $1.2K (no explanation needed)
DRUMS
MOOG DFAM $.8K (for grit)
ARTURIA BSP $.2 (for control of the dfam)
ELEKTRON ARMKII $2K (for all the drum machine you need)
POLY
ACCESS VIRUS SNOW $1.2K (for supersaw)
ROLAND JV1080 $.4K (for strings and pads)
ELEKTRON A4 $1.8K (analogue chords)
KORG VOLCA FM $.2K (for fm sounds)
SAMPLER
ELEKTRON DIGITAKT $.8K (for one shots)
FX
KORG KAOSS PAD $.4K (for glitc fx)
STRYMON BIG SKY $.6K (for pads)
LEXICON MX200 $.3K (basic reverb duties)
MODULAR $1.3K (for crazy making)
CASE
BRAIDS
WARPS
FH1
ROLAND BITRAIZER
Budget blown…
$3000 computer with Ableton
$5500 monitors
$1000 RME
$500 midi controller
Digitakt (sampler and midi nerve center)
Digitone (best FM ever)
Prophet 6 Module (bi-timbral future classic)
Midiverb II (P6 1st set of outs, Bloom presets)
Lexicon PCM 81 (P6 2nd set of outs, creative multi-fx)
NOS Waldorf Microwave 2 (yes NEW- https://rover.ebay.com/rover/0/0/0?mpre=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ebay.com%2Fulk%2Fitm%2F152969855133 )
OTO Bam (for MW2- lushness)
Nord Lead 2 Rack (Autechre stuff)
Ensoniq DP/4 (for the NL2 separate outs)
Moog Minitaur (low end beef)
Moog DFAM, Make Noise 0-Coast and Sherman Filterbank 2 (sampling stuff)
Earthquaker Transmisser pedal (insane reverb)
Neunaber Immerse pedal (gorgeous reverb)
Greenhouse Retro Sky pedal (phased delay)
Lefty’s Sound Lab Noise Rumble (distortion fx)
mint condition Mackie 1604 (non-VLZ… above 4 pedals on sends/returns)
+best Genelecs I can afford with the remaining funds
$1200 Octatrack
$1000 room treatment
$1000 interface
$2500 monitors
$3000 computer
$1300 in software
give or take…
Stressed out just thinking about how I’d spend my imaginary budget!
Assuming we’re starting over from scratch…
Naw, I can’t do it! Fairly pleased with my rig as-is for now
This is a fun little activity. I make really weird ambient stuff so my choices might be a little out there… lots of pedals.
Synths:
Moog Sub 37 - £1,100
Moog expression pedal - £50
Samplers/noise makers:
Elektron Digitakt - £600
Pedals:
Strymon El Capistan - £250
Old Blood Noise Endeavours Dweller - £200
Red Panda Particle - £250
Chase Bliss Warped Vinyl - £350
Digitech Whammy - £150
EHX Superego Plus - £250
Chase Bliss Dark World Reverb - £350
Critter and Guitari Organelle - £350
Line 6 M5 - £100
PSU + pedalboard: £200
Field recorder:
Zoom H5 + Shotgun mic capsule - £300
Computer stuff:
Ableton Live - £350
Launchpad Pro - £200
Focusrite Interface - £200
KRK monitors - £250
Audio Technica Headphones - £250
How’s everyone gonna run these setups without cables? 
Oh shit. Budgets blown. Kitty empty
Studio bling will be good to admire at least 
Id be really interested to see what people would choose with a much tighter budget…
Thats already desert island tight!
I disagree 
Yep, reckon we add another 10 grand at least 
Moog One
OTmk2
Genelec monitors and a few cables with what is left over
Done. Minimal deluxe setup.
Edit: I am almost there, just need to get the Moog One and the Genelec monitors. 
Some sort of digital piano and a copy of Reason would be enough for me. Assuming I’d need to add the cost of a new laptop + interface + speakers, but nothing fancy. Should have plenty left over for a few cables.
- MOTU 16A
- Yamaha NS-10s
- Roland SH-101
- Machinedrum UW MKII +
- Monomachine MKII +
- Octatrack MKII
- M.I. Clouds
- M.N. Morphagene
- 4ms Dual Delay
- Boss SE-70
- Alesis Quadrverb
- UA LA 2A compressor
i would get about the same live rig as i have now, but with modern sequencer instead of venerable groovebox ) so, something like this:
sequencer:
- Squarp Pyramid
mixer/recorder:
- Zoom LiveTrack L-12 (i’m happy with it)
synths:
- Blofelds (2 or 3 units)
- PreenFM2 (3 or 4 units)
- Novation Nova Laptop (yes, i am necrophile, so what?
) - Yamaha DX200 (the only one in the list that i still don’t own)
controllers / input devices:
- Novation ReMOTE Zero SL (i told you that i am necrophile)
- Novation Launchpad Pro (2 units)
- iRig Pads (2 units)
misc:
- ESI M8U eX — MIDI interface
- Axoloti Core (at least 2 units) — various supplementary tasks
that’s it.
monitors, computer, DAW/plugins are considered beyond the scopes of this list.
yeah, if you add up how much it would cost to replace what you have - it becomes scary quickly… these things tend to build up over time.
( a good reminder perhaps for us all, to check our insurance is up to date!)
If I had to start again, I think Id largely buy the same again, perhaps some minor changes for ‘fresh’ inspiration, drop a couple of things i do not use as much as i used too , but main instruments would remain.
but for me, this is no dream proposition, more like a nightmare as Ive got a couple of things which Id find really difficult to replace (like my Eigenharp Alpha) which are not available to buy, and virtually impossible to buy secondhand - id be gutted!