That’s a great point. However I still think if I have a guitar and a microphone I am in a much safer zone to be organic and ‘musical’ even if making mistakes and just playing with the silence and the sound.
I’ve done less electronic (which was not sophisticated) and felt it far more stressful.
Mainly because - and this is totally genre related - electronic performance audiences, if they are in the niche you are performing to, which is usually a small niche, are massively precise in their expectations.
- it’s too derivative
- i like the start, but then he ruined it with those pads
- ouch, way too much time on that arp section, hate the hats
- this is totally inconsistent - funk then techno then ambient
- what am i watching here, is this any good, it is original - did i hear a BoC Chord, a Radiohead beat, an apex BassLine? Oh no, not another Richie Hawkin. What is this, rare 45 funk hour?
Whereas get up with a guitar and sing and play like you mean it, with arguably far less technical talent than it takes to pull of a true live 3 or 4 machine electronic set … and you can emotionally pull your audience in with more ease as you aren’t expending massive technical dexterity that isn’t appreciated.
So long story short, if you can get up and pull off an electronic set and it is appreciated, you have some real talent to do all the difficult technical coordination AND get the crowd to feel it. It is not easy. It is a real leap if you’ve built up a bit of a name and people know you are playing your own creations and building it in real time.
Someone once told me after a lot of rum, that the term Disc Jockey was really on point. In a horse race it is the horse that does the running, but the jockey gets the praise though they chose the horse.