I didn’t think Moog One or the other analog polys in the room were terrible - they all sounded “analog” in the way I expected them to, and in a good way. It’s just that Prophet 5 sounded so much more inviting to me. As an aside, I also preferred my friend’s Memorymoog over Moog One, as far as sound character. First time I tried the MM, I though “meh, overhyped”. Then my friend said something was busted inside and he planned to fix it up and bling it a bit. After the job was done (broken key replaced, new power supply, electronics repairs, new LEDs, etc.) holy smokes it sounded amazing.
EaganMatrix Eurorack is supposed to have MPE already, as well as tuning tables and 8-voice polyphony (over MIDI). I’m favorably inclined towards it despite not hearing it specifically in person yet, because I played Continuum in person before, which, as you know, also has the EaganMatrix multi engine.
Pro 3 is under consideration.