Summary report on the Theoryboard. (My opinions.)
The mechanical hardware is excellent.
The most important thing first. The pads have a good feel to them, slightly softer than a Ableton Push 2. I find it’s good to bend the response curve to add more to the soft side (i’m using UVI KeySuite mostly at the moment). I wish there was a way to set the response curve in the TB.
It’s nice that the physical zone on the melody side where you can put your finger and get two notes next to each other to play together is small. So if you are sloppy with your finger you often get the right note anyway, or at least usually not two neighboring notes. It is possible but you have to try hard to do it.
But you can trill with one finger if you want. Octave trills and rhythmic staccato repeats are fun too. And expressive staccato runs and patterns are easy to do as well.
You can’t play two chord simultaneously, only one chord at a time, but you can trill between them.
The keyboard is heavy enough to stay in place, but it’s not a burden. And it’s sturdy.
Also very important – i find the TB musically interesting and stimulating.
I’d quibble a bit about the arrangement of the buttons on the controls in the middle. The capacitive touch is good, once you are used to it – a couple of days.
The key and modal change buttons are great, i think they are capacitive too and they are fast, and recess on them makes it a positive action, and are seldom miss hit.
The software is good, but has room for improvement. But they did do a very good job with the thing about software of primary importance – no serious bugs! I have been using the TB a lot – it’s addictive – and have had zero crashes or failures. Occasionally when i’m really banging on it and doing things in unpredictable ways i have had MIDI note hangs, but it’s pretty rare. EDIT: I’ve discovered the cause for this, and a fix. Not sure this is really a bug. See NOTE at bottom.
Annoying thing (a cosmetic software issue), when you select a key it is arranged in this order A, Ab, B, Bb, C, D, Db, E, Eb, F, G, Gb !? Goofy isn’t it! I think it got arranged alphabetically rather than chromatically. That will be an easy fix for them, and something to do right away.
I’d also adjust the way the menus scroll and move, and some other human factors issues, like thinking about menu depth. They would do well to contract with a human factors designer. A few hours critiquing by a pro would help them a lot. (A human factors person would probably have helped some before they laid out the center control panel, but it’s quite tolerable and good enough.) Human factors people must be a dime a dozen in the Bay Area.
That all said i was using the control panel the first day without a manual, so it’s all pretty good. I’ll leave it to you to figure out how to move the melody keys up and down octaves. It’s not hard.
I’ve had some time wondering about the chords chosen to match with the scales. (You can read more about the scales in the next post.) When i spread the chord out i sometimes wonder why they pick a particular note to be in the base. It varies some across the choices for a particular degree of a chord, and sometimes there is no chord with the root of that chord in the base. But that said they sound good, so there is probably a reason for the choices made.
I’d also suggest Irijule use the blank buttons on the right hand side of the melody keys as duplicate keys. It would be nice sometimes to be able to play further to the right rather than having to wrap back all the way to the left side to get to the next octave.
Very much as i anticipated it is causing me to improve my standard keyboard playing too. It’s expanding my chordal choices – which is worth the cost by itself to me for the TB. Plus i am getting to discover cool scales, like the Prometheus scale. More in the next post.
I’m playing this thing a lot, and enjoying my time with it – so it’s worth it’s cost in that way too. I have also been using two hands on the melody side and playing chord harmonies there as well.
When my Hydrasynth arrives, toward the end of this month, i’ll get a chance to test the poly-aftertouch on the TB.
NOTE: On MIDI note hangs. This has to do with the chord and melody on the TB as shipped using the same MIDI-channel. If you play a melody note that’s in a chord being held, the MIDI on and offs become nested. The fix is to set the TB to use two different MIDI channels.
Theoryboard Scales
Since there is no documentation yet, i figured i’d put together a description of the scales and scale modes. I’ve listed the scale categories on the TB, and then show the first mode in each scale in C and the interval map.
First i list the 7-note scale categories. There are 7 modes of each available inside these categories as well – and of course these are available in all keys. Sometimes these modes have names sometimes they’re just called something like “Blah mode 3”.
Additional detail in case you don’t know, you can always flip any scale back and forth into chromatic mode – using the “12” key; and the in-between notes are in light blue. So they are there if you want to play chromatically.
=====================
Note: These are all distinct scale categories except for the Melodic Major and the Melodic Minor which are modes of each other, and so are essentially the same just shifted around in modes. But the chords for these two are different, so they are different to play. I plan to explore this some more, to get a feel for the differences between these two chords.
=====================
Now i move on to the Pentatonic group, all 5-note scales obviously. The arrangement of these scales is a little more ad hoc. The scale categories listed have no modes under them in the menu. But there are modal relationships between the categories.
The Pentatonic Major, Egyptian, Man Gong, Aitussen Yo, and Pentatonic Minor are all modes of each other, and completely span this note arrangement.
The Iwato Japanese, Chinese, and Hirajoshi are modes of each other.
The In Sen Japanese stands by itself with only one of its five modes presented.
Curiously there are seven chords presented for these 5-note scales. Using the colors you can see where the missing chords sit. And the “missing chords” sound really good in this too. This strikes me as genius. The melody never resolves to that chord – leaving a mystery.
=====================
Now i move on to the Other Scales group. There are two 6-note scales in this group, and three 8-note scales.
The first 6-note scale is a 12 Bar Blues scale. Hopefully everyone is familiar with this. Nice choice of chords with this, a good minor feel to it, and worthy of study with a standard keyboard once you work something out. And again seven chords with this 6-note scale, and no chord for the “blue” note.
The next is a 6-note Prometheus scale:
There is an interesting set of chords here. There are many I and II chord choices in this. The first chords are both major triads even though the “fifth note” in the I is outside of the scale. It can be happy sounding moving between these two. The iii and iv are diminished. And the v (added extra chords again) and vi are minor. The vii is augmented.
Then there are three 8-note Bebop scales.
The note that gets added to these three scales that changes these scales to bebop scales from there similar 7-note scale is light blue in color. I put the red dash in the graphic here. This is a good idea and helpful, but unfortunately light blue is also the color of the between notes when you switch to chromatic mode so you can’t distinguish the bebop note in chromatic mode.
I would really have liked a Whole Tone scale and an Augmented Scale. Maybe later.
EDITED: For a correction/clarification on Oct 4th.