OPXY vs Digitone 2

I’ve had both these machines, and a bunch of other grooveboxes, push 3 standalone, analog four mk1, OP-1/OP-Z, and for whatever reason I’m not coming up with ideas or finishing tracks on these things, I always end up just going back to the DAW and recording my analog synths or collaging samples from various stuff. When I had my syntakt and Perkons, I’d make a beat on them, sample it and move on fairly quickly. The digitone was a replacement ‘drum machine’ when I sold the Perkons, but having it in the studio, I just haven’t really gotten deep with it. The OPXY joined the studio when they had that weird choose your price sale, and it definetely feels more useful and portable than the push or more featured than my op1/z, but alas I’m still not getting tracks done.

So, I’m curious of those that have had both an OPXY and Digitone 2, how you’ve used them? Did one win over the other? My plan is to pick one, mainly as a bedroom/sofa jam thing rather than connected to my larger studio, and really try and learn it and engage with it. Just trying to decide which way to lean really. They both now have multi out capabilities to finish stuff. One is pure synthesis whilst the other has samples. I’m think I’m always going to finish stuff off in ableton, so it’s more about finding and creating vibes/grooves on. Also, the whole portable make on a train/plane thing for me is a fantasy I’ve tried and doesn’t work for me, turns out I’d rather read a book, so it’s his doesn’t need to be, can I take this to a coffee shop decision either.

Interested to hear your thoughts!

1 Like

yes- I have OP XY and Digitone. OP XY gets used in everything as a MIDI sequencer for desktop gear that has no sequencer, portable groovebox. I don’t sample a lot with it.

2 Likes

I own both and personally don’t think they’re similar other than being a small/portable synth

I can’t really get “acoustic” sounding drums on the DN, so for me I only really use for pads/leads/bass. Really complex sound design and powerful sequencer, chord/scale functions are great to quickly be able to work in one key (not hella strong in musical theory). DN is extremely deep and feels endless in some ways, but sometimes I don’t want to set up the sounds and don’t really have kits worked out to quickly load presets.

OP-XY is super fast on the other hand, the way template is set up from the jump, just load a new project and everything you need to start a track is loaded. Seriously fast to get going, replace sounds you aren’t feeling, and once you learn the shortcuts, nothing I’ve tried has been faster. Synths on the XY aren’t as deep/complex, but definitely not as bad as people make it seem. If you have some favorites from other stuff, sample and make a preset. Portability and flexibility with other gear is not easily matched by other pieces on the market. (M8, but that’s a whole diff vibe)

Also don’t think either unit would be great on the couch with, prolly the XY more than DN, but still find I prefer to have some flat/stable surface to use.

2 Likes

Why don’t you just go back to these and keep making music, instead of forcing yourself to work with machines that don’t click for you and now probably spend even more money?

3 Likes

Feel like having some templates in n the DN ready to get going with musically might suit my brain rather than dive straight into programming, which I’m much better doing that on other gear.

I’ve also been slack at putting my own samples onto the XY, which was down to the older OS friction, and I just haven’t sat down properly again to look at that.

And also, @Azzarole yeah that might be a solution. Part of the process I think for me is trying stuff out too to see what works, and I also totally get the search for the grail of groovebox stuff I totally get caught in that trap too. Guess I’m trying to give all these things I already have a good run still before making that kinda decision. I’d potentially pick up a Perkons again, I love knob per function of that musically. I did start to hit a wall with a lot of the output sounding samey though and also have hours of jams and stuff I can sample too.

2 Likes

Or you just found your sound, you know?

It’s hard for me to tell from the outside. I agree that it’s interesting to try out different stuff and find out what works for you, what different kinds of machines lead you to etc. But it reads like you’re mostly struggling and wasting your time at a point where you already found something you enjoy and liked, so why bother? Not everything is for everyone and if you don’t like it after you’ve spent a decent amount of time with it, probably worst idea to buy a beefed up version of what you don’t like (DN2).

1 Like