Yeah, I was on the fence about the Octatrack. Nearly purchased one. I’m a Digitakt owner and I’ve tried every Elektron unit in my local synth store.
I think the main problem with it for me is that its just old. It was a very cool piece of gear when it came out but the MK2 didn’t improve it and modernize it, just gave it a new shell. Its one of those pieces of gear thats been around for awhile and people still recommend it but its just like the OP-1, theres a lot of hype and positive talk around it but I feel like the devices just haven’t kept up with the industry.
Both devices came out around the same time and both just don’t sound amazing anymore. Small self contained production machines weren’t too big in 2012 so having both of those devices come out was great. But now theres quite a few options that sound MUCH better.
I’m very happy with the Digitakt. Its the hardest hitting drum machine I have and just sounds incredible. But even the Novation Circuit which is like $250-$300 sounds better than the OP-1 and Octatrack.
I sold my OP-1 after having it for 5 years for the same price I bought it for. Its a cool device for what it is but that thing has such a trash reverb and the effects in general are mostly pretty bad. I found myself using it less and less as a portable music making device and more of a synth that I’d route through Ableton and layer effects on. To me, thats not worth $800 or so when a big selling feature was its portability. The 4-tracks used to not bother me that much, and it still wouldn’t if the tracks were actually stereo. Having 4 mono tracks that could be panned on to one stereo master is just so goddamn restricting. The sequencers, apart from the Endless sequencer that works like most hardware synth sequencers, were mainly trash.
I feel the octatrack hasn’t aged nearly as poorly as the OP-1 but the confusing work-flow just seemed too much. My best beats in my opinion were made pretty quickly. And having to dive into menus and stumble through an interface can really drop my desire to be creative.
I ended up ordering a Deluge by Synthstrom. I’m excited to see how that turns out. Seems like it will be the perfect replacement for the OP-1 for me and you can make full tracks with it.