Great post, refreshing honesty - much appreciated!
Can’t speak for everyone, as I don’t use the Launchpads Ableton integration at all (I only use them in custom mode).
I can give you a bit of feedback in general though (I have quite a few hardware controllers on my control surface area, 5 Launchpads (3 LP-X, 2 MiniMK3), 6 LaunchControl XL’s, 2 LaunchKey MiniMK3’s).
STUFF LAUNCHPAD DOESN’T DO THAT I’D LIKE ON MYSTRIX:
Customizable Off AND On colours PER PAD - (Novation all pads share an ON colour, per page). Blinking colours would be great too.
Radio Buttons - (single pad, press to step through different colours, each colour sends a different message, note, CC, PC, also specific CC values on one CC).
PC/NRPN/RPN - be able to send these from pads.
SHIFT FUNCTION - have a shift pad, which could work as a modifier for any pad to give a pad a secondary message.
SHIFT BETWEEN TOGGLE/MOMENTARY - perhaps a SHIFT pad could either allow another pad to send a secondary message OR when held down it will force a momentary pad to act as a toggle (or vice versa). I often want a momentary and a toggle of the same CC, I currently have to use 2 pads for this.
STUFF LAUNCHPAD DOES DO THAT I’D LIKE ON MYSTRIX:
Responds to incoming MIDI messages - and light’s up appropriately according to the mappings on the page.
Consistency Across Pages - If pages share a control, and I change that control (either by pressing a pad or via external MIDI, all pages are updated that use that control).
MY CONCERNS
Build Quality - I know you said your LP-X broke after 6 months, but my experience has been the exact opposite, all my Novation gear still works perfectly, it feels absolutely solid. I’d like this level of build quality on any controllers I buy.
Longevity of App - Would an app be updated over the years to remain compatible with computer OS upgrades etc.
OTHER THOUGHTS
Currently the Launchpad Mini MK3 and LP-X do not have sequencers. Only the more expensive (and very large) LaunchPad Pro has a sequencer.
I think many people might be interested in the sequencing side for small hardware setups.
Would be great to post some videos here, showing very clearly and simply all of the features. I’d like to see things like changing the pages using the side buttons (how quick and easy is it during performance), how easy is the sequencer to use, which version of Bluetooth does it use, etc.
Thanks for making this, I have a huge amount of respect for smaller companies and teams doing this, it’s extremely valuable to the music community as a whole, and I hope you sell a ton of them, and a community builds around it.
Maximum respect to you all for making it open-source, customizable, and offering replacement parts.
Hope my thoughts helped in some way!