Can someone enlighten me what the midicake arp brings to the table that the NDLR can’t?
Though close to each other, relative to all other music hardware, ARP and NDLR are quite different devices. They are each deep and create complex and evolving patterns, yet have a very different approach.
NDLR is a great device, I have one and have explored it a lot. So here’s my view…
Unlike NDLRs 7 chord interval approach, ARP doesn’t try to help you when it comes to chord selection, a downside maybe but your freedom to explore chords and scales is pretty much unlimited (within Western music scales at least).
The biggest difference though is that ARP will track your incoming MIDI notes and create sequences that follow along, in harmony. NDLR on the other hand will transpose incoming notes, to its internally selected scale. ARP will do that if you are not using an external device.
I initially started work on ARP to meet a specific need… playing many synths together and all in harmony.
For an excellent demonstration of this, take a look at Jay Hosking’s latest jam: - https://youtu.be/d5xK471xlJ8?si=S88VP5frgYJaN0dE
When NDLR was launched I bought one but found it didn’t fulfil that original need I had, so I continued ARPs development.
I explain that need in the “Shocking Revelations” video, SirAdrianFish posted
I wanted the melodies created to be based on my rules and not pre-programmed sequences. That’s why it uses a parametric approach to sequence generation.
ARP has Pattern and Groove editing, multiple modulations, chord chain sequencing and is very intuitive as a performance device. It’s also very deep and the parameter matrix gives almost unlimited freedom for exploration.
It’s also deterministic, so even with its ability to play Poly Rhythms and even modulate time signatures and groove/swing, you’ll never get out of sync and when you press Stop, then Play. There’s no danger of losing the lovely sequence you just created.
Or maybe they can even be used in a synergistic way together perhaps?
I’ve been meaning to publish a video on using NDLR and ARP together. One great way is to use NDLR’s Pad channel as the note sync source for ARP and let ARP track NDLR.
Another is to create long-evolving patterns with ARP and get NDLR to transpose them.
Quite different results but a lot of fun.
I hope that helps.
P.S. I am of course biased towards ARP, but I’ve tried to give you the key differences and I do still love messing with NDLR!