I’ve played around with OB in Ableton on my AR and Akeys (the latter was an A4 until yesterday; YES!) since it came out, but today was my first chance to spend some quality uninterrupted time with it. It was a great experience in many ways, and frustrating in equally as many.
The good: I was able to set up an Ableton template that addresses my full wish list workflow wise. In addition to the VSTi and tracks for recording audio from both instruments, I have MIDI tracks set up that allow me to play clips in Ableton on either instrument AND record them into the Elektron sequencers. And then I have a drum rack built for the AR so I can record MIDI from either the AR pads or the Akeys (using as an external midi instrument) into Ableton on one track. And of course I can also play and record soft synths within Ableton using the AKey MIDI ext.
It’s very convenient and tidy and I think puts me well on the way to a workflow I’m going to enjoy. I like working in Ableton, never was an OTB guy in the first place. So I like the idea of having the MIDI clips that I can always go back to at any time and edit. I will still record these in the Elektrons and take advantage of P-locks, performance modes and all that. And when I’m ready, I’ll record audio into clips and start building arrangements ITB. At least that’s how I think I’m going to roll…
So the bad: I have to say, overall I would rate OB as very buggy indeed at this point. I have a list of things that went wrong over the course of the day, but honestly each of these issues popped up earlier while messing around with it since its release.
-
OB freaks my Apogee Duet 2 out big time, or the Maestro 2 software I should say. When I change routings in OB control, the Maestro window opens and closes like 10 times in rapid succession. Same happens when I open a VSTi or turn on one or both of the instruments. And then it crashes. EVERY time. Spinning beach ball from hell. Today I just closed it and gave up; it still passes audio as my sound card. I’ve made sure I’ve got the latest firmware and software, no go. I know it’s OB related because it works perfectly as it always did before OB if I work on a project without Elektrons and OB.
-
Live almost always crashes when I quit after using OB. Fortunately I saved all day without issue, but as soon as I quit it crashes. Live had been incredibly stable for me pre- OB
-
I get VERY frequent audio drop outs. Just a ton of holes everywhere. It’s rare to be able to play through a 64 step sequence without a drop out in one track or another.
-
I get frequent low bitrate noise patches, which someone here described as sounding like a ring modulator. Fortunately these go away on their own within 64 steps or so. They come and go…
-
The sync in recorded audio is not consistent. I’ve seen it dead on and I’ve seen it off by as much as a 16th note.
-
Today I had a really weird double BPM kind of issue that I vaguely recall someone else mentioning. This is the only problem that I’ve only seen once. I can’t recall the exact circumstance leading up to it, but I had just recorded audio clips and they played back at roughly 2x the speed. The audio LOOKED normal, but the playback was crazy fast. And then it crashed so I couldn’t really look into it.
So I don’t know enough about computers to know where to look for answers here; it could well be something in my system as far as I know. Here are some stats:
— Late 2009 mac mini (old, I know!!) 2.26 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo, 8 GB ram
— Yosemite 10.10.3
— Latest version of OB, the 1.0.0 Ableton one
— Latest AK and AR OS
— Using a hub - this 7 port cheap one that the website said was multi TT, but I’m suspicious.
— Ableton Live 9.2.2
I will also point out that I’m new to Yosemite, got it just for OB…
I’m tossing this out here to see if anyone else can relate to these issues and we can find some patterns. It has SUCH AMAZING POTENTIAL and I really want to work this way. But for now, it’s just impossible for me. Way too buggy…