DAW Latency Questions (Newbie)

Hello, I own a few keyboards and drum machines, and recently purchased a microphone for vocals. I have been jamming with my equipment for many months now and would like to record some simple pop songs. From my research, it seems that a computer and DAW is the best way to record music. Before spending a lot of money on a new computer and audio interface, I have a few questions concerning latency.

This is what I want to do:

  • Record drum machine beats into the computer
  • Play a keyboard part over it
  • Play more keyboard parts, add vocals, and maybe synthesizer sequencer parts as well
  • After I am done with a song, take care of volume levels, panning, EQ, fading things in and out, etc

I do not want to use any software synthesizers or monitor with FX or anything. I want to use the computer and DAW almost like a tape recorder and post production mixing and editing station only.

Now, to my understanding, this is the problem: I have learned that some audio interfaces have a knob that allows me to listen to what’s coming out of the computer and what I am playing, so there will be no latency when I am actually recording. When I listen to the drum beat I have recorded, and when I play notes on my keyboard, it will sound perfect. But once I have recorded this keyboard part and listen back to it, it will be all wrong, everything will be late. This is because of latency.

Is there a way to deal with this? Can I ever make it so that my recordings will actually be as I play them?

I know another option is to purchase a small audio recorder that can overdub like a zoom h5 or mixpre II along with a mixer. But to my understanding, these are much more limited for editing. Also, do these have problems with latency?

Please excuse my ignorance. Thank you very much.

Bump in case no one saw this.

A few things that can help us help you.

  1. What DAW are you using?

  2. Are you currently using an audio interface or just the built in audio on the computer?

  3. If you don’t have an audio interface, are you on a Mac or PC?

1 Like

Thank you for your response.

  1. I plan to use Reaper. It is free and seems to be very good according to what I have read online during my research.

  2. I am currently using nothing.

  3. I am leaning towards purchasing a Mac but am still considering a PC because they can be much cheaper.

Reaper and a PC would be fine for recording, mixing, and arranging, music.

You will need some kind of audio interface. It doesn’t need to be crazy expensive or fancy.

Audio interfaces come with drivers (software written specifically for that audio interface).
The drivers give you low enough latency to write music. It also gives you inputs to record the full quality of your instruments without high noise levels of built in audio cards.

You can start with just a small interface.
Focusrite has a decent set of smaller interfaces (just an example).
You need set of stereo inputs and maybe something that has microphone preamp combo jacks on it. That way you can record either microphones or instruments using the same input jacks (at separate times of course).

If you already have a computer I’d say your next purchase should be an audio interface. That will give you lower latency and allow you to record without the latency problems you’re experiencing.

1 Like

There are no ways to actually eliminate the latency? What about latency compensation?

No–but it’s fine. I mean think about it: You’re hitting a key that’s transferring data to a synth that’s being converted to analog and transmitted through an audio cable into a preamp of an interface then converted to a digital signal which is being sent to a computer software program (and I probably missed a couple steps!) It is physically impossible for latency to be eliminated.

But you can get it extremely low. If the latency is low enough you won’t notice the difference, and all interfaces come with some ways to change the settings so you can change how low or high the latency is. In general–the lower the latency the more CPU is used–but that’s fine–especially if you’re not running a bunch of plugins like you say you won’t be. People bump up their buffer size (what determines latency) in order to mix so that way they have the most efficient CPU usage. It’s not uncommon to go back and forth between ASIO buffer sizes.

2 Likes

Thank you for your response. That was very informative.

1 Like

No problem. I forgot to answer the other half of your question:

Because the people who make DAWs are smart little cookies they’ve built in latency compensation under the hood. So let’s say your delay is down to 50ms, well hypothetically that would mean (if you’re playing to a metronome) everything you record into the DAW will be 50ms late.

But DAWs are smart, and they shift it back 50ms automatically. Or something. I’m actually not entirely sure how it works. But it does.

2 Likes

PCs are significantly cheaper and there’s nothing Macs can do that they can’t–except run their exclusive programs (Logic, Final Cut, what have you)–but those programs aren’t worth the extra $1500 price of admission–especially when there are so many great alternatives available.

I have an awesome Lenovo laptop I did the majority of my mixing work on up until recently. I bought it refurbished off ebay for under $300 and it came with Windows 10, a solid CPU and 8GB of RAM. I love that little guy and the only reason I’m not using it currently is because I decided to do more video editing work and upgrade my desktop PC. I kept my same graphics card from my desktop, but everything else (mobo, SSD, CPU, even new RAM) was purchased. All in all, if I had bought everything brand new, outright–it would’ve been about $700. I can guarantee you a Macbook or iMac with similar specs (I’m talking specs that can run any new video game on the market, and do a bang-up job of editing videos, too) would cost at least $2000.

Apple is a racket. Don’t waste your money.

2 Likes

Except share the same MIDI inputs and outputs with multiple programs or plugins.

Oh, and plug in MIDI or Audio interfaces without having to shutdown your DAW and start it back up.

You can also create aggregate audio devices where you combine multiple audio interfaces from any manufacturer into one interface to use in your DAW.

You can also use different audio interfaces for inputs vs outputs in your DAW.

And the MIDI and Audio routing studio built in to the OS is handy for getting ports named what you want, and doing routing outside of your DAW between audio devices and midi devices.

Also core audio low latency audio is the standard audio driver on all Macs so you get fairly low latency without an audio interface (though I still would recommend one for better quality and even lower latency).

There are a few differences, but both are very capable of making music with. No need to to buy a Mac just to make music if you already have a PC and are happy with it.

I’m still using my 9 year old quad core iMac as my main studio computer. It got a little slow over the years (hard drive was wearing out) but I recently upgraded the hard drive to a solid state and it’s running like it did 9 years ago :slight_smile:

I personally like using OS X for making music because of some of the reasons above as well as personal reasons but those aren’t going to be important (or necessary) for someone just starting out.

2 Likes

Ha! I suppose I’ll plead ignorance then. I’ve never heard anyone else talk about those features before…

Really? I’ve seen threads before where people put their Macbook to sleep while plugged into an audio interface and shit gets weird (just like it would on Windows).

That’s interesting but I don’t know why I would ever want to do this :man_shrugging:

Yeah this is something I noticed about my friend’s macbook (which she paid $4000 for…) when she was playing back her track without an audio interface. I was quite surprised.

I just got on the SSD bandwagon and I’m definitely a convert. I’ve waited far too long.

I also forgot to mention that UAD products are only available on the Mac ecosystem, but they’re also insanely expensive (about 5x as much as other comparable interfaces) and, as far as I can tell in A/B comparisons, the difference between their software and Waves software is ALMOST unidentifiable…Something you can never really hear in a mix. UAD sounds good for sure and I record on it often with my buddy, but again I’m not sure if it’s worth the price of admission. $3000 for an 8-channel interface (with some cool plugins) and $2000 for a laptop is a hefty price to pay. You can pay 1/3 that and use the leftover money to buy a good mic, a good synth, extra software, whatever.

1 Like

Reaper is not free even though they let you use the demo indefinitely. The price of a discounted license is so low (60$) there no point in not actually supporting the development team by purchasing the license.

5 Likes

@GirTheRobot That latency compensation is just what I was looking for! May I ask, what is MIDI latency? If I make the DAW the master clock, to send out tempo and start/stop to a drum machine, do I need to compensate for that? Or is MIDI latency only important when using a MIDI controller to play a software synthesizer?

@jefones I will gladly pay that amount, it is so cheap it is practically free. It still beats many of the other DAW prices I have seen.

If you dont Plan on using plugins and just want to record, then you don’t need amazing specs. Get a halfway decent interface that fits your needs, set a low buffer setting (32/64) with 48khz sample rate. From what you described that should be the best setting. You wont notice the latency in that setting.

2 Likes

@loopdude Will an i5 6 core be enough? or should I go for i7?

If you only want to record, an i5 would be sufficient. If you plan on mixing whole tracks I’d go for i7. Hard to answer.

I think you should splurge and future proof yourself. Better to spend an extra $100 now and not regret it in a year or two, than to spend an extra $200-$300 in the future. I’ve definitely made this mistake before.

2 Likes

If you can afford it go for de i7

Handy if you want more inputs/outputs than one interface has, and have another interface, or piece of equipment that can also act as an interface, such as the Digitone.

A big benefit of the UAD interfaces is that it takes the processing load off the computer for the plugins, helpful if you run a lot of process intense effects, and a godsend for older computers.