I’ve been using Softube Tape for a long time but haven’t encountered this issue before. Whenever it’s active in my signal chain, it introduces digital artifacts in the high frequencies that sound like bit or sample rate reduction. They start at about 3.7 kHz.
Here’s a recording of a filtered synth arp that begins with Tape active, then I deactivate it, then activate it again.
I’m in Ableton 11 on Mac OS High Sierra. As far as I can tell it happens regardless of what else is going on in the project. The recordings I made and the testing I’ve done have been in projects set up for that purpose, with just an instance of Ableton’s Analog synth as a test sound source and then Tape and Pro-Q 3.
I don’t have 10 but I just tested in 9 and had the same issue. Very strange. I’ve opened a support ticket with Softube, hopefully they’ll have answers.
I have also noticed that the artifact changes as I adjust the speed stability setting in Tape. This is the only setting in Tape that seems to affect the issue, so I figure it’s related to that feature somehow.
The representative I’ve been speaking to at Softube claims to not hear a difference or an issue in my A/B test recordings, which I’m not sure I buy. The bitcrusher-style ringing in this file and this file I sent them is pretty clear and obvious to me, and not something the plugin should be doing.
I’ve set up this Live set with a test tone coming from Operator that isolates the artifact and shows how it changes when Tape’s speed stability parameter is modulated. If anyone has a moment of time and uses Live and Tape (or is willing to install Tape’s free trial), I’d greatly appreciate it if you could record this test for me to get a comparison with another instance of it running on another machine. Thank you!
Welp I had a friend test it out and he was able to reproduce the issue on a different MacBook running a newer OS than mine. Softube, after awkwardly denying the issue despite the recordings I sent and without even trying to reproduce it, has stopped replying, so I guess no one really cares lol.
Not really keen on a plugin introducing unwanted artifacts into my signal chains so there’s $100 USD down the drain.
Just in case someone out there also experiences this, I thought I’d give an update. Support eventually got back to me and said their engineers had reproduced the issue. They said they would try to figure out a fix, but after two years eventually told me they couldn’t. My ticket was closed and they offered me a small voucher for a discount on one of their products.
I’m still very surprised no one has noticed this, or if they have noticed it, is okay with it. Any time I have bell-type sounds or filtered resonant pad sounds go through Tape, it sounds like I’ve put it through Decimort with the sampling rate reduced or something. Quite annoying.
I’m a bit baffled that a plugin I paid this much money for has a defect like this, and after two years of waiting, all I get from Softube is a shrug and “here’s a coupon so you can buy another one of our products”. I guess it was good to know I wasn’t going crazy?