Why is Reddit going dark? Many subreddit now private and here's why

More accurate than you thought you might have been when you said that. The Reddit CEO was quoted in recent days praising Twitter’s approach to “cost-cutting” and said he had had a couple of convos with Musk about running a digital platform.

Forums do not scale well. A sense of community and good moderation (related, as we have seen here) are needed. Anything private that gets popular is subject to the inevitable degradations of capitalism; anything public or quasi-public tends to get swamped. The only reason niche subreddits could sometimes maintain quality for a while was obscurity.

Reddit to me was always a tire fire, much as USENET became. It’s annoying that so many search results now deadend there, but search is broken anyway. Mastodon is quieter than Twitter, which suits me right now. If you want the feeling of being plugged in, be prepared to have your other orifices invaded as well. I don’t expect Lemmy to replace Reddit. Something else will snatch the crown for a while, before the investors take their pound of flesh.

4 Likes

While I am somewhat happy that reddit seems to be withering on the vine and it indulges in a bit of schadenfreude I do worry that the few of the forums I frequent might have a culture shift due to a reddit exodus. Sort of like going to a punk show in high school only to see a lot of the people I was avoiding who happened to heard RHCP on the radio and want to try their head at stage diving but do it feet first. But, I’m a mercurial over-sharer so who am I to talk…

1 Like

yeah, that 30 days notice is a dick move…

Said no one ever, Home Depot rocks!

2 Likes

That’s for sure but they do sell bags of rocks for 9.99.

4 Likes

which home depot is that fantastic deal at? mine are much more expensive.

3 Likes

Well, you should check their site and enter your zip-code it will tell you which stores have that only to discover that the sales associates didn’t even know they carry bags of rocks because I guess they weren’t the ones carrying them off the pallets.

1 Like

Couldn’t see if this had been posted above, but someone on r/synthesizers started a Lemmy instance, which seems to have a spread of topics, that people in this community could be interested in.

Reddit post: Reddit - Dive into anything

Lemmy instance: https://waveform.social/communities

Just signed up myself.

1 Like

I’ve been on Reddit a long long time, and have recently deleted the apps and won’t go back. The attitude displayed during the stouch with Apollo/Christian basically made their position on to not just developers but the user base too perfectly clear.

There were definitely some fun and interesting communities, but few things can replace the quality of a dedicated forum like Elektronauts.

For the rest, Lemmy is the place now. Feels pretty rough and ready like the nearly internet, but that’s a good thing. There’s a heap of the most active posters from Reddit there now too, so it will build critical mass pretty quickly.

4 Likes

yet another stupid move from reddit, it’s like they are trying their best to kill every premium subscription and be left with ad driven site

2 Likes

rest in pepperonis

thank god i needed a new reason to stay away from there

7 Likes

spez doing everything in his power to kill that website, paywall for a user generated website is a pro tech bro move

Exactly, think of it like a sin tax on wasted time.

1 Like

Reddit died for me when they killed 3rd party apps, baconreader was the best. Nowadays I use it less anyway. Worst I hang on elektronauts, and get GAS instead.

2 Likes

Honestly same. The moment this happens I overwrite my account with one of those macros and then delete it.

1 Like

They must be very confident about the number of people who are so addicted to reddit that they can’t function without it to even consider implementing this “move the entire culture behind a paywall” tactic.

1 Like

Reddit, the home for the world’s most terminally online people.

3 Likes

That reminds me of those people who pee in cups so they can keep mmorpg’ing.

1 Like

That’s amusing, but not really a surprise.