Who believes in karma and have you got personal examples?

Let me fix that for you.

And disagreeing is completely fine. You are choosing to live with your head in the sand though. I envy your ability to do so. Happy for you. :slight_smile:

2 Likes

I’ve been Hindu-adjacent for 43 years so, yeah, I absolutely believe in karma…
But here’s the thing: Like all matters of spirituality and religion, its a question of faith, not of being convinced by observation of concrete evidence. Some people need very little to choose to believe in something outside this tangible world, other people will never believe even if Jesus appeared right in front of them.

1 Like

I won’t try and convince you of anything. None of my business. But at least let me say that your claim of how karma might work is missing the crucial element of reincarnation. If the subject acts selfishly and under the influence of the ego, they perpetuate their own suffering in the future, whether it is in this life or subsequent lives. Again, I know you don’t believe in it, and that’s fine, but the teaching of karma does not allow for the “largest arseholes” to be the “most rewarded”. That wouldn’t make any sense :upside_down_face:

1 Like

Yeah, I’m using it on the way most people understands it, which is the way OP is using it. I have no comments regarding reincarnation etc, so not touching the OG way at all.

2 Likes

Karma, like faith, seems to be nothing but a comfy blanket.

For me, anything beyond admitting that you have no idea about the meaning of this existence is pure escapism. That is, all religion is pure escapism from the fact that we will never really know the true meaning of this existence. There’s nothing wrong with escapism as long as the belief system you escape into does not judge or harm others.

3 Likes

:face_with_raised_eyebrow: why? is that a common thing? never heard about bacon in air fryer…


no I don’t believe in karma as a spiritual thing “what goes around comes around”, like how can you even tell? to me it’s the same as people claim divine “miracles” or “punishments”, don’t believe in such things.

as for your bacon situation, you probably just ate too much at once or the air fryer trick is not that good for bacon, not really karma :slight_smile:

2 Likes

My locus of control is too internal to believe in karmic responses for my actions. I think it’s far more helpful for me to give extra attention to my own attitudes about things that happen or that I might do. I don’t necessarily believe or disbelieve whether there is a force in the universe that’s responsive to what I do, and nonetheless it wouldn’t be something I could fathom or change. But my own response to the things around me seems to be under my control, and that certainly impacts a lot. So lately I try to focus on having a good attitude and good intentions.

1 Like

I was angry with my friend and wished him a bloody red synth. Next day in my mail:

7 Likes

I think I’m having BLTs on whole wheat for dinner now! Thanks! Dinners a bitch to sort out!

Non of that air fryer assholery though, bacon will be cooked on the gas griddle while enjoying a cold beverage or two!

3 Likes

this is the way, Bacon + Cold Beer + Digitone

3 Likes

Indeed! I often ask myself who has it better than us, no one!

3 Likes

Before we get into Karma, I’m not sure that informing the restaurant benefits them. Individual ingredients are a relatively small part of the cost of a meal, and no sane restaurant is going to take back food to sell to another customer.

Keeping the bacon and cooking it for yourself is a perfectly reasonable thing to do.

Based on my understanding, the way I’d boil down Hindu-Buddhist cosmology is roughly: we live in a society and the things we do can impact ourselves and others in surprising ways. Try not to be a jerk, but also don’t get too upset at people who haven’t figured that out yet.

My own view is that hydrogen ions (which make up most of the mass of the universe, if we ignore whatever Dark Matter turns out to be) don’t care about humans. Human morality matters to humans, so it’s on us to figure out how to live well together. If g-d, or Jesus or Allah or various Bodhisattvas or tree spirits or giant robots help you to be a better person and treat others well, then that’s excellent. Doesn’t matter whether your inspiration is “real” or not, what matters is that you treat yourself and others well.

I consider myself an optimistic nihilist: nothing matters, and that’s good. It’s on us to build a pleasant place to coexist.

In the extra bacon case, I’d leave a bigger tip next time, if this is a place that accepts tips. Or just some kind words about how delicious their food is otherwise.

4 Likes

You know that thing astronauts experience when they look back at the earth from space and realize that every person they’ve ever known, read about, or has had any impact on anything in any way is within their field of view and they’re completely humbled on a spiritual level?

Now imagine being the person next to the astronaut, looking at them looking at the earth, and realizing that everything the astronaut is experiencing about all the experiences that have ever happened are all happening within the tiny microcosm of the gray matter in their brain. None of the rest of it matters to the astronaut. None of it even needs to exist. They don’t have to be in space. They don’t have to be looking at the earth. The earth doesn’t even need to exist. The only thing that matters to the astronaut is that they are thinking of it as if it does.

All of which is to say, the entirety of existence is, for each one of us, not an abstract and distant thing. The totality of it (or, at least, the only operative parts of it that affect us in any way) exists within us, inside our brains.

So now think about the last person you were a jerk to because they were being an asshole and so clearly deserved it. Did you show them? Or were you actually a jerk to a part of your own brain?

How did they react to it? Will you ever know? Or will the only recordable results of your being a jerk only ever play out in your own imagining of what the copy of an asshole in your head feels?

Isn’t the only person who feels anything in response to anything you do yourself? Shouldn’t you therefore do nice and good things?

That to me is karma.

7 Likes

Shots fired

4 Likes

Given how many people I know personally who have physically received eggs from the Easter Bunny, I should think the evidence of its existence is irrefutable.

7 Likes

Karma for starting this thread is that I’m gonna mute it, LOL.

5 Likes

Hope you’re not cooking the Digitone in a bloody air fryer.

4 Likes

Griddle

3 Likes

From some anecdotal accounts that likely came from children? I have much higher standards for the evaluation of evidence. I say we capture and study this creature to see if there’s any voracity to the claims.

3 Likes

Hard to argue against that.
And funny to see it brought up in a thread like this as they’re both commonly misunderstood/ misused terms. Nihilism is a very useful jumping off point to explore other philosophical disciplines as well as being useful in its own right.

4 Likes