First off, thank you everyone for the amazing input and replies. It’s both helped immensely but has also caused me to consider even more possibilities. It would take way too long to reply to everyone individually so I’ll try and hit the main points that I’ve seen being echoed.
First, while I have no doubt that the octatrack is amazing, it seems wayyyy too complex for me and to be honest I just dont have the time to put in right now to properly learn something like that (aside from music I’m trying to finish my PhD along with teaching, running a photography business and organizing events on the side) so something that can be picked up relatively easily is somewhat of a must so there’s more time creating and less time learning.
Second, many of you suggested looking into mk1 products and while I’m sure they’re equally as good the screens are kind of a big deal breaker for me. The price difference between say a rtym mk1 and a rytm mk2 is worth it for the screens alone in my eyes (pun intended).
Third, I’m not sure if I made this clear in my OP but I intend to pair this all with a DAW (ableton). Because of this, I dont think something like a song mode is entirely needed for me. I basically intend to get grooves going on whatever hardware I choose and then record into my DAW for arrangement. I mostly just want some hardware to play with so that the process is more interactive than just arranging samples in a DAW.
Fourth, many of you have suggested a Digitone as well. Ive considered this although to be completely honest FM synthesis seems pretty intimidating.
As it stands, I plan to get the sub 37 for sure, that’s the guaranteed purchase. By this thread, it seems like the best option would be to pair it with the Digitakt and the more I watch videos on all of these devices (I’ve probably watched 12+hrs of youtube videos this week), the more I agree. The thing that was drawing me to the Rytm mk2 were the analog engines for drum synthesis. It’s still very attractive to me but I’m unsure if that is worth the price difference and loss of some features. I would also like to pair a second synth to this setup and am considering a bass station 2, Digitone even though FM synthesis scares me a little, minilogue, or perhaps even an Analog Four mk2.
Looks like I have even more to think about now.
Edit: I forgot to ask, do any of these mentioned devices offer sidechain compression? To the best of my knowledge it seems like the Digitakt does not although I may be wrong. Although live performances is not a huge need of mine, and I would do this in my DAW anyways. It would be useful to me while jaming out grooves during the creative process.