The OT recording process is rock-solid and repeatable all day long.
From what you’ve written I can’t tell if you fully understand recording trigs vs. playback trigs. Changing trigs from yellow to red or in reverse has nothing to do with it. There are separate subtracks per track (trigs, slide, swing, and rec.trig). To see them, enter grid mode (by pressing Rec) and then hit Func+Edit to reveal the Rec.Trg track.
Also, sell it to me before you toss it in the trash 