Good tips, my bets on mechanical issue or cold solder joint.
Op amp? Probably not.
Use your finger as a probe.
Because the phono amp is very sensitive it is a nice trick to make some noise by touching components to discover the audio path until you hear the missing channel. Then you can make a guess where is the break in the circuit.
Of course watch out for high voltage parts but they are well separated if not external.

2 Likes