Agreed, absolutely no animosity on my part I can assure you
I was taught in the early 90s at South Manchester college to mix down to create dynamic range, perhaps it is no longer the norm, but Iām too old and set in my ways to change now as itās always served me well. I still do wonder if my box has an issue and Iām getting a different experience to you and others, although Iām certainly not alone.
Just wanted to say im in ableton 9 with the same problem too,
I just recorded a pattern in and the loudest track was the kick peaking at -27.37
with most things averaging -40 to -50 db
My digitakt patterns play at about a third of the volume of mp3s, youtube and stuff within windows.
Im on win 10, have just updated overbridge to 17 (was on 12) didnt make any difference(firmware 1.11 not the beta)
In usb config usb to main is +12db and iām on post fader.
When I switch to int to main on it matches the windows volume on playback but still only peaks at -25db when recording but then I have to switch back to int to main auto or I hear the pattern from the digitakt not from ableton, then iām back to hearing it at a third of the volume to windows again.
Checking back to the only other thing I recorded a couple of months ago while on the firmware beta, the levels are fine peaking at -14db and I can see the waveforms, admittedly I didnāt have the digitakt setup in plugins folder then though as I had just done it as my first test and it worked across the 8 audio channels.
I personally like to keep my track levels super low, then just use a single trim plugin on the master bus to bring up my master level.
This thing about needing hot levels for the faders doesnāt exist. All modern DAWs use at least 32bit floating point, some even use 64bit float mixbusses. With that amount of resolution, there is absolutely no scientific need to have tracks peaking loud.
But its a foolās errand trying to convince anyone otherwise⦠heck, most VST plugs already peak above 0dB at the channel level just opening up the default init preset. And the UIās of DAWs also cater to these absurdly hot levels, by having calibrated the default waveform rendering to scale to expect such nonsensically hot levels.
The fact of the matter is - users expect über-hot levels because theyāve been taught to expect them. And DAWs have immense headroom that makes them almost impossible to internally clip by accident, enabling such ālegacyā practices to be utilized. I say legacy, because in the 16bit nineties, yes, you actually tried to use hot levels everywhere because there was practically no resolution to go around with. But⦠this hasnāt been the case in ages,
TL:DR = none of it matters. there is no way to win. As long as it sounds good, its good. Elektron should probably give in and add that 6dB in there. People will not change their habits.
As a test I have removed my plugins folder and setup ableton to record the 8 channels of audio from the digitakt which is how i previously had it setup when I did a test a few weeks ago and the levels were ok around -14 to -24. Now they are still -28 to -50 which plays back at a third of the volume of my digitakt , the waveform cannot be seen and is consequently really difficult to work with (despite the theory in practise it is a different matter)
This is something that has happened to the windows drivers since I upgraded the digitakt firmware from the beta to 1.11
Is anyone else on windows having this issue ?
Do electron people comment on these forums or should I be speaking to them direct?
It has been noted on this thread, but send an email requesting it anyway, I did. Hopefully it will be addressed⦠I find this thread frustrating and have been staying out of it lately.
Stumbled upon this thread after Googling āRytm too quiet through Overbridgeā. I donāt want to stoke the āflamesā - I just want to share my setup & āissueā.
Iām running USB audio from a Rytm Mk2 and Digitone through an Overhub into Overbridge + Ableton Live 10 on a MacBook Pro.
The Digitone is nice and loud, but the Rytm is super quiet, and the main volume dial does nothing (while the main vol. dial on the Digitone works).
Doesnāt feel like a deliberate design choice to me.
Not if you are recording directly to stems, you just get a bunch of invisible waveforms. Not everyone is processing the output, and it would be simple enough to reduce volumes if the levels were higher, it has nothing to do with headroom, its a digital signal thatās too quiet.
There is noise. I can hear it clearly on my headphones. When increase by 6db using Utility in Live 10 and then record my plugin I can hear that noise is recorded as well.