Hi!
I’ll jump into this discussion as well and I’d like to mention the Analog Rytm MK2 (not MK1), because it has a good balance between possibilities and limitations. Currently my AR MK2 is my centerpiece for my productions and my Liveact show, because it works like my “vinyl crate” where I have many tracks, that I mix with my Octatrack to a full DJ style Liveact.
When I produce on my Analog Rytm I can - of course - create all the drums and percussions on the Analog Rytm (because it’s a solid Drummachine). But for the synth part I us the AR as an Audiointerface and hook it up to my MacBook (DAW - Bitwig Studio - 1000x synth plugins) OR iPad. On my iPad I have a few synths where I like the sound and the sounddesign with my hands.
The AR can act as a basic MIDI sequencer and in conjunction with MIDI plugins from my DAW (MacBook) or DAW (iPad - Drambo for instance) I can jump above that AR MIDI sequencer limitation. For instance: I can insert a MIDI Chord plugin in my DAW and all my monophonic note patterns from my AR will convert into chords that then trigger my Syntht plugins.
Those virtual plugins can also be routed directly via USB into the analaog tracks from my AR, so I have the analog filter and distortion on my virtual plugins. The combination of an iPad/Notebook with synths etc. and the Analog Rytm MK2 offers a lot of sonic possibilities to shape whole tunes ![]()
On the perfomance side I think the Analog Rytm MK2 is the best machine Elektron did so far. With the performance pads you can very quickly assign a bunch of sounddesign parameters to one pad. For instance: lowering the filter on all tracks can easily be done with the press of one performance pad. BUT: you can assign those performance pads to one real Encoder with a start and end position and this is gold for the feel while you perform. AND: you can add multiple performace pads to just this one Encoder (Quick Performance Encoder). AND: those performance macros can send MIDI, so you can control virtual plugins from DAWs with the Pads and Encoder from the AR.
In addition you have Scenes where you can assign multiple parameters to the Pads and can activate or deactivate those snapshots.
And then you have the Fill Button, Page Loop, Pads for Fingerdrumming, Mute Mode etc etc.
In the End: you can translate those Performance related functions to musical arrangements phases. Thats what I did! What encoder do I have to dial in, when I need a transition from my main part to my break? What Pad do I have to press to bring the focus on to the synths??
If you like the jelly fat rough sound from the AR, the limitations (Mono samples, 1x filter per track etc.) but also the nerdy possibilities, you can ask me anything
I could write a lot more, because in combination with the Octatrack you can do whole livesets, have fun with Sample Slices playing from the Rytms Pads … and I didn’t wrote stuff about sampling … so for me (as you probably hear), the AR MK2 is my favorite timeless machines Elektron has ever build. But I always loved to jump above limitations and boost my creativity with those.
My suggestion: if you wanna play and perform, go for the AR MK2. If you like design tracks and arrangements in a more “programmer way”, then maybe the Tonverk could fit your needs.
Best, Kai