I feel you. I use the 828 Mk2 now for several years as a digital mixer/patchbay (CueMix is quite nice!) and I have the impression that some tracks made with my Mackie 1642VLZ had a bit more punch.
But that is my totally unscientific personal impression
The Ultralite Mk5 sparked my interested because I could use the 828 Mk2 as a ADAT expansion, while I could the newer preamps of the Ultralite for more “important” channels like my main MPC or the most used synths. The second advantage would be, that I could use an iPad for multitracking all the channels into Cubasis for example. My current laptop is seven years old and I’m torn between buying a new laptop or a new iPad.