Multitrack recording volume is lower than Overbridge

Hi. I understand that overbridge is designed to record at -12dB for headroom. But I am trying to record multiple tracks on my Syntakt through overbridge on ableton live. And when I try to record a kick (for example,) it comes in at -12dB on overbridge and -26dB on a track thats routed to the kick.

How do I get the seperate tracks to match the volume on Overbridge?

Thanks,
Grayson