I could have posted this in the thread about regrets after selling gear as well, but here we go. I had an A4 MK2 for about 1 1/2 years and sold it four months ago. I really liked it as a desktop synth due to its form factor. I also really liked performance macros as an idea.
In practice, I came up with a few nice ideas and patches, but always struggled to evolve them. Unlike Digitone, which is also quite deep but still approachable, as soon as I tried to tinker with sound and make variations, it all collapsed and got frustrating. I had several last sessions before listing it to see if I have an “aha”-moment and never had, but never sold it nonetheless. When I finally did, I felt relieved and never regretted it.
I also didn’t really gel with the sound. I found it particularly disappointing that I could almost never execute a filter sweep that sounds nice, which is like the most basic thing that brings you joy in an analog synth usually.
But now listening back to stuff I recorded with it, I suddenly appreciate its particular sound a lot more. It’s rather thin sound makes it possible to make patches that sound fragile and naive. And you can make quite basic sounding patches that still have an interesting subtle character to them with all the modulation options. It also sits brilliantly in the amateurish jam mixes I recorded with it.
I think I wanted a “phat” sounding analog sound and didn’t really see/hear what many of you are raving about here. Maybe my ears are now better after two years of more intense music making, so I can appreciate the A4 sound more.
I replaced it with a Syntakt eventually and was convinced by its analog sound from the get go. But after a few weeks, I find the Syntakt analog melodic stuff great for basses and some leads, but feel quite limited by the amount of parameters in the synth page.
Dang, now I’m seriously considering buying one again and giving it more time. I will definitely keep the Syntakt as it surpasses A4 as a groovebox and songwriting tool by a mile. But I think I can now appreciate A4 as a synth rather than a groovebox.
Edit: listening to more stuff I realize that A4‘s a bit more tame sound makes it an especially great candidate for thickening that sound with effects without muddying the mix. I found that I‘ve used Microcosm and Specular Tempus quite heavily on some of these recordings. A4‘s own delay also really shines.