If you had to choose one, which one would it be and why?

orbax · 2023-05-18T05:58:38.736Z

Yes, I once heard her or your @jeanne industrial sounds over the a4. without flattering myself, i have to admit that this is on a very high level. i produce more ambient stories like this and i once had the a4 and had difficulties creating a pleasant sound quickly, while i also had the minilogue and got very quick results here. But it is interesting what many write here and I think maybe the a4 will get another chance. he can definitely do certain sounds like a 303 or deep floating unison drone quite well.

orbax · 2023-05-18T06:02:23.527Z

yes, waldorf and virus are always on my mind. my dream is to be able to afford the quantum at some point i think the blofeld would be able to fit in here in terms of price, but then I prefer the cheap analogue one, because i wasn’t really happy with the blofeld at the time either. I’ve never had a virus, but everything I hear is great.

natehorn · 2023-05-18T06:14:16.720Z

craig:

Digitone. Sounds great. Much easier to navigate than A4, which is rammed full of menus and submenus and involves so much paging around. A4 is not quick or intuitive imho.

For me it’s the opposite! Digitone is fairly bewildering for me - lots of options that don’t make sense to me and I often struggle to get the sounds I want.

If you understand subtractive synthesis then A4 is so much easier to work with and I get to something fairly quickly with it. Having recently picked up an A4 its giving me everything I was trying to create with the Digitone without having to watch tutorial videos and bending it against its will.

I think it really depends on the kind of sounds you want to create!

A used MK1 A4 is an absolute bargain.

For the OP though I’ve recently picked up both a Minifreak and an A4 - I think they compliment each other well If I could only have one though I’d take the A4

LyingDalai · 2023-05-18T07:36:08.748Z

I’d go for an A4, having 4 different voices at the same time is very convenient.

A4 needs learning.
I’d say less the options in themselves, that are many and will get you busy for some time, than getting a mental map of the attainable sounds.

It’s not a synth that get you something interesting in the first 20s you own it, most definitely. For someone who wants immediacy, I would not recommend A4.

There are interactions between oscillators waveforms and levels, filter distorsion and resonance, and all the modulations you can set including hidden (second menu’s) ones that need a lot of tweaking before you understand how get control over your sound design. Once you get some interesting timbres, save a Sound patch like you’d plant a flag on uncharted territory, and soon enough you’ll have a shortcuts to reach quickly a sound you have in mind.

It’s only once you’re there that fun starts, and when you exhaust the sequencing possibilities you reach places other synths can’t even dream of. Sound locks, Direct Jump, FX sequencing, slide trigs… A self-sufficient and unconventional synth, really

Lokua · 2023-05-18T07:46:29.330Z

I don’t have an A4 so bear with me: what exactly is the comparison, here? Seems to me the A4 is a great machine for multiple monophonic parts like a drum sound, bassline, melody, whatever. But after a quick look it seems cumbersome and not well suited for chords like a polysynth. The other machines listed are polysynths. Having to pick one…well, doesn’t that depend entirely on what you want to do?

Rics · 2023-05-18T07:49:08.412Z

Lokua:

But after a quick look it seems cumbersome and not well suited for chords like a polysynth. The other machines listed are polysynths.

You can obtain poly by using it as a single part with 4 voices or with each mono part, using OSC tuning of OSC 1 + OSC 2 + SUBOSC set at 5th as 3 notes chords (with P-Lock you can set a different chord per step easily, there’s also a chart somewhere in the forum).
Add detune, and you can get it “FAT”.

Lokua · 2023-05-18T07:51:50.330Z

Yeah I get that, but again to my comment, it doesn’t seem well suited in that regard. 4 voices is quite limited, and manual tuning of oscillators is cumbersome. Don’t get me wrong, still useful, but in context of A4 vs machines with more voices…idk, just seems like a weird question to answer with “X is best”

Unifono · 2023-05-18T07:56:45.115Z

The arturias and the minilogue xd have loads of digital options and can go into very different territories than A4 or minilogue… so the comparison is difficult.
The A4 has four separate tracks on the other hand, you can do full songs on it. In this regard none of the others is comparable.
If we’re comparing only the subtractive synthesis side of things the A4 is the most flexible. Otherwise the arturias have by far the widest sound spectrum I assume.

Another big difference between the A4 and the other synths you mentioned is the interface. Groovebox form factor vs keyboard style synth with loads of direct controls

Starscream · 2023-05-18T08:04:31.406Z

Get the priciest one so I can resell to get the next one at lower outlay. Not sure of the purpose behind the question here - is it sound quality, is it for live performance is it to make synth wave sounds etc…?

orbax · 2023-05-18T08:14:15.763Z

It’s mostly about the sound quality and the price. you can get all these synthesizers very cheaply on ebay. in the context of polyphony they are all limited anyway, with the mini freak having the most voices. yes i may be in a situation where i need to sell the rev2and temporarily have to decide on a replacement because the rytm will definitely not be sold. I find it very difficult to decide which one it will be, so I’m asking here. in addition, i prefer analog devices and these devices are analog or hybrid.

Laser · 2023-05-18T08:18:30.437Z

Do you have external/centralized sequencing or not?

Do you want more to write songs quickly or do you want to dig deep in sound design?

The A4 is better if you dont have external sequencing.

Minilogue XD or Minifreak for quicker/simpler sound design.

A4 if you need the option of using as 4 mono-synths. Minilogue XD/freak if you have better monos already.

I was faced with this choice too. I chose the Minilogue XD because it fitted my needs better.

I’m glad I did, because it sounds soooo good, fully loaded with custom oscillators and FX. I’m not much of a sound designer, I pick one of Jexus’s patches, change the multi-engine and tweak from there. For me it sounds better than many more expensive polys etc.

The A4 sounds okay, can sound great if programmed well, but never makes my jaw drop like the MxD does.

All in my opinion, of course. Enjoy choosing!

orbax · 2023-05-18T08:24:12.073Z

the sequencing doesn’t matter here, although i prefer elektron’s. it is interesting. I don’t know if it’s because it’s an elektron forum. in any case, the majority prefers the A4.

Laser · 2023-05-18T08:34:36.209Z

Are you asking because youre interested in buying for your own setup?

If so, I would be asking myself whats right for me, not whats right for everyone else!

I think its down to:

Do you want to dig deep in complex sound-design?

Or want to write songs quicker or have simpler one-knob-per-function sound-design?

Actually there are other questions too. But thats what will help… asking yourself questions to get to the root of the issue.

There’s nothing wrong with buying and selling, chopping and changing synths, in fact in some ways if you learn on each one it can help you a lot.

However, you might want to avoid that faffing around and get it right (for you) first time.

Look at what you already own. Ask yourself questions!

Fin25 · 2023-05-18T08:41:10.402Z

Lokua:

But after a quick look it seems cumbersome and not well suited for chords like a polysynth. The other machines listed are polysynths

All but one of the list are four voices.

orbax · 2023-05-18T08:42:12.966Z

I’ve been producing for many years and yes, meanwhile I have my own ideas here quite well. I know all these synthesizers. I’m still asking here which of these is preferred and why. it will be sad if i have to sell my rev2 and it might be a little nice to hear which one the majority thinks is the best.

hausland · 2023-05-18T09:46:08.364Z

For me, the versatility of the A4 is unmatched by the other synths in your list.

A4 sounds great (if you know how to handle it) and offers so much possibility on the sound design AND sequencing front. It‘s a beast and the A4mk1 is criminally underpriced in the used market atm.

LyingDalai · 2023-05-18T10:48:40.987Z

Lokua:

4 voices

I thought Minilogue XD and Minifreak were both 4 voices as well

Edit: oh, the Freak is 6!

Jeanne · 2023-05-18T11:04:40.074Z

Some people prefer multitimbrality over voices (like me)

reeloy · 2023-05-18T11:22:54.981Z

…an a4 mk1 for actual 2nd hand prices is a must have no brainer…period.

Lokua · 2023-05-18T15:45:42.940Z

Oops. Didn’t realize the others were that limited. Well in that case…