Tanzbar kicks should also be in this conversation. I’ve had a lot of fun recently layering the Tanzbar 2 kicks with a noise sample loaded into a Tanzbar 2 sampler track (which has an analog filter and bitcrushing).
That being said, the MBase is probably the more sensible option
Learn the Digitone.
Might be the most powerful synth you own and you don’t know it.
FM is not hard, you just have to keep looking for the right entrance door.
This was mine:
I’ve tried an explanation here:
Now the kick is an easy thing to synthesize.
The right one may take time, but you should imo take some time to explore what you can do with what you have.
Piggybacking on Dalai’s recommendations to add Dave Mech’s Digitone course — in Part 1 there’s a series of videos walking through the creation of a kick from scratch, you can see which parameters to reach for if you want to achieve a certain kind of sound or edit a particular aspect of your kick. Really great stuff.
I’ve never used the same kick twice, for the past 25 years since I’ve started making music. And I mostly make psytrance, where it’s common to do what you’re suggesting
On the topic:
DN is the most flexible kick machine ever. And I say that having searched for the kick graal for years, I prefer it to all dedicated kick vst I tried. But you need to deep dive and learn how to shape it as you like.
ST is great when you need a bit of kick flexibility, but don’t want to tweak for hours.
Finally, don’t sleep on DT: even with samples, you can easily shape any base kick drastically different using pitch, filters, OD and most importantly LFO shaped as exp decay envelope
You can use the DN as a regular subtractive synth, in fact for kicks you mainly want a pitch modulated sine wave (or triangle for Xtra grunge) which is easy on the DN
I appreciate the advice, everyone. I’m going to do a deep dive on wavetable synthesis for the Digitakt (really love the sounds I’m hearing people make with that) and mess about with the Digitone more. It’s honestly hard to imagine what I’m looking for isn’t in there somewhere!
The Jomox 09 contains some of the most devastating kicks I’ve heard. Take Blawan’s word for it. I know this might be an odd opinion but the DN has always felt like the most complete Elektron machine for me. It’s one of my favorite FM synths w/the chromatic keys, and the percussion is just ridiculous. Super sine-y subs and chirpy hats. The snares don’t really smack or thwack, but everything else is so lush.
Just to be clear: I’ve been there!
I’ve actually been deeply hating FM for decades. Until I understood that it was also a way to get incredible sounds. I started reading about it right before the Digitone came out, and have been a FM lover since.
So yeah, just try again! You already got awesome tools!
In a year from here, when you’re a FM master that can do metal, glass, plastic or wooden kicks, you’ll forgive me for having insisted…
Try this on the DN : innit sound, mess around for two minutes with the parameters so you don’t have a pure sine wave anymore, then activate portamento and set a portamento time. Play a very high note, then a very low one. There, you have a decent starting point to a good kick without being an FM wizard. Sample it with the DT. Voilà.