Great battle guys! Really different styles which made it difficult to judge. My top 3 is more a matter of taste than anything because all of you showed great and very different production skills and styles.
Top 3:
3 points - track 9
2 points - track 4
1 point - track 11
Hm: track 1, track 2
My notes on all tracks:
-Track 1 : very nice! Four seasons? first part was my favorite: dope drums, dope buildup, dope stab. Great switchup between second and third part. Fourth part nice, very wu-tangish. Would work well for ghostface.
-track 2: great, cinematic sound. I like the subtle things going on in the background and I love the choir coming in. A bit too distorted on some sounds for me, otherwise completely up my alley production wise. My top 3 changed a lot and this one just missed out in the end.
-track 3: dope chopping. Very original sounding, very creative. The beat has just the right amount of things being added/changing to stay interesting throughout.
-track 4: Love the drums here, hard hitting but very subtle/finessed at the same time which I respect a lot. Reminds me of madlib beat kondukta stuff (some of my favorite instrumental hiphop) because of the atmospheric sounds.
-track 5: nice distorted sound on the guitar. Cool bassline, cool use of reversed and chopped sounds.
-track 6: nice buildup from the intro. The chopping reminds me of dj premier in the sense that the silent pieces create tension here. I like that it keeps changing but the cadance of the track keeps up.
-track 7: I like the sound of the drums on both pieces. The layering of different melodies in the guitar part is cool.
-track 8: wow talk about an energetic intro. I know the ferrante & teicher song very well, would never have thought of using it this way. I like the westcoast vibes here.
-track 9: this something I would listen to while riding around the countryside on my bicycle. Very nice bounce on the drums. Both the drums, vocal bits and bass groove give me Dilla vibes. Very nice beat.
-track 10: Cool abstract sounds and bounce here. Somehow reminds me of a psychedelic beatles track in some way.
-track 11: instant snap on the snare. Nice use of layering different stabs on the main groove. This sounds like something I would like to have made myself. Great beat.
-track 12: wow very loud and distorted! Reminds me of a beat Run the Jewelz would kill any time. Great use of pitch effects and stutters without killing the bounce of the track.
-track 13: another one on which the drums immediately grabbed me, both the sound and the groove. Nice menacing sounding stabs. Another layer on top of the main loop wouldve pushed this into the top3 for sure.
-track 14: Dope haunting guitar loop! The horns layered on top are soo nice and subtle. I think this track would really take off if the drums were double timed and more boombappy, but thats a matter of taste. Great produced beat.