Diminishing returns in making electronic music

I’m experiencing massively diminishing returns in music making – wiggling knobs is seriously less fun than it used to be.

I have (mostly, so far) avoided the temptation of throwing more gear at the problem, trying to find out the why instead. Obviously, all of this is completely subjective, but I’m wondering whether others here have been in a similar position, what you have done, and what you thoughts on the subject are.

(Warning, long-ish post.)

I think one of the problems is that, once you have the hang of it, it’s kind of easy to sound like 70% of the stuff out there, all of which kind of sounds the same (90% in the case of certain genres) – which is not a bad thing necessarily, it’s genre music after all. In the beginning I found this extremely satisfying – hey, I sound just like all the cool stuff I saw on Youtube! However, for me, this quickly flipped and turned into boredom. Which is strange - why can’t I simply enjoy making music, regardless of what and who it sounds like? I never had the intention to publish songs or make a living from music. As a hobbyist, I shouldn’t care less about the other stuff, so why does this feel demotivating?

The answer is, for me, not at all the other music out there in the end. I think it’s a lack of feeling authorship with electronic music. I don’t have to do anything really to make things sound cool. I don’t have to work on my tone, like the folks who play acoustic instruments. The guys at Moog or Korg or Sequential or Intellijel or Makenoise or … did that for me. And if it doesn’t work, there’s reverb and whatever granular effect is fancy these days. I’m just navigating between sweet spots thousands of others have explored before. (How many reviews of FX have you seen, where somebody uses phrases like “instant ambient machine”?) It’s a bit like taking photos in tourist hot spots. Go fancy with cool chords and key changes? Nah, adding Fmin maj7 add 13 over B# only sounds muddy on a complex waveform. Just throw an LFO at another parameter.

So, what to do?

One way out is to take on the producer challenge of making really really really good genre music, which probably means to invest a lot of time and money in really learning production, mastering, and the like. I’m guessing that this is the area that sets the top 30% of genre music apart from the rest, rather than the actual instruments, let alone musical sophistication. I admire people who are good at this, including so many on this forum, but I don’t want to go this route, because this inevitably means a more complex setup, more gear, and, worst of all, much more time on the computer, which is what I want to get away from by making music.

What I’m gravitating towards is something else: I have recently played around with my wife’s piano. While she plays Bach, Satie and Mendelsohn I’m struggling to find my way through simple chord progressions with inversions, but man this is so satisfying! If I want something to sound cooler, I cannot simply reach for another LFO or change the reverb algorithm. I have to find another chord inversion, add a 9th, change my rhythm, work on my left hand, etc. (Also, I’m quite blown away by the subtleties of even simple piano sounds, and the way that thing changes timbre over octaves. And it has 88 voice polyphony!) It’s super hard, and I’m pretty sure I’ll never sound good enough to share much of my music, but it’s so much fun just doing it. It has this feeling of I am making music. Or am I just excited from trying something new?

So, I’m pondering whether I sell all my synth gear or whether there is a middle ground. After all, I still love many of the sounds of analog subtractive synthesis. The Prophet 10 is temping, which was called the “piano synth” offering nothing to hide behind by another member of this forum. Other polys are tempting, too, or maybe a stage piano with a decent Rhodes?

Anyway, thanks for reading to anyone who made it till here. I’m quite curious to hear whether anyone of you has experienced something similar. And where you went from there.

32 Likes

Set a goal to perform live - that where a real rush of music comes from!

I get what you mean, and I felt the same for a while, until I discussed the genre that real resonates with my artistic direction. Then I found everything feel into place and I became very focused on the minor details…

15 Likes

Ok. If you’re not enjoying it, no one is forcing you to keep doing it. Do something else.

The idea of getting a return is wierd to me. But if you want to feel like you’re getting something, or somewhere thats cool.

Do what makes you happy. Sell all your synths and take up banjo, or fly fishing, or pottery. What ever brings you the grooves.

Personally I’m having more fun now after 12 years of electronic music making than I ever have. I gave up chasing genres years ago. I just make what I enjoy, what I have fun with. Bollocks to what anyone else thinks. I’m happy twiddling knobs and seeing what comes out.

12 Likes

I go through those phases of losing the spark from time to time too. I have spent long periods of time not doing any music at all. Wondering what more I can say, how I will ever top what I did before (not in a bragging way, more in an “aware of my limitations” way).

Usually, the spark comes back when I change something about my music practice, or more broadly my creative practices. But it takes time and the transition period is usually painful, I think that’s what you’re going through right now.

Like you I’m an amateur, and I don’t want to spend time or money on too many technicalities, I just want to apply the bare satisfying minimum. So you’re right, our interests have to go somewhere else, and I think the main focus should be on novelty and expanding our comfort zone for a while.

Try something new and dedicate a good amount of time to it. View it as taking a holiday somewhere to recharge your creative batteries. Make music in another genre, make a concept album, explore new ways to use your gear, create a soundtrack for your days, learn about minimalist, generative or algorithmic music, make shit music deliberately, or try to remake tracks you love. Even explore other forms of music practices or even other arts like you’re doing.

For example, I felt stuck a while ago and I started learning ink painting for a while. It felt awesome and so refreshing to be a beginner again, and after a few weeks of practice and learning the philosophy of this art, I naturally felt the urge to come back to music, but with a whole new take on it.

I think you’re on great tracks with this new interest in piano playing, and I would suggest you keep your gear, keep it dormant for a while and focus on the piano. Try to have a goal, like learning a few songs you like, or maybe even record some songs you composed. And then after a while, just be open to that spark being lit up again.

8 Likes

I’ve been making “electronic” music on and off snce I was about 10, which was 31 years ago. When I Was a teenager, I made a few tracks but I basically didn’t care so much about the output or what anybody thought. The thing is, this was pre-YouTube etc and I didn’t know what everyone else was doing. So I was probably trying to sound like some music I knew from the Radio/TV but that was it. Now, we’re in an era where everybody who does anything puts it online so there is the risk of constantly comparing yourself with others. I hate the whole culture around that and it’s awful with music production. The quality of a lot of the content is bloody awful but it just makes you feel inferior anyway if the idiot making the videos can do something slightly better than you can. Wobble bass, anyone?!

I think it’s natural for interest levels in hobbies to ebb and flow a bit so I wouldn’t worry about it. Try something different or just leave it alone for a while and when you come back it might feel fresh and interesting again. Anything can become boring or repetitive if you do it too much.

Don’t put pressure on yourself. If it isn’t the way you make a living then you can do it as much or as little as you like. It really doesn’t matter!

16 Likes

Learn to go with the flow. So you like playing piano. That doesn’t mean you won’t find joy in playing synths. Sell some stuff you’re not feeling though, always good to get rid of clutter.

4 Likes

That is a terrifying thought, but a really good point!

Even though I’m far from good enough to go live, it might be a good idea to team up and make music with others. In contrast to other genres, electronic music is often a very lonely enterprise, but it does not have to be. (Pandemic permitting, that is…)

3 Likes

Regarding live performance, I think even getting away from what most people do with a DAW (sequencing) and just turning it more into an organic jamming thing can be a whole new experience. It doesn’t have to be in front of an audience to be “live”.

I keep trying to find this with various gear but it’s clearly not the easiest thing to get right. If you’re trying to find the perfect “jamming” setup but you’re always 5% away then you’re in good company on this forum!

4 Likes

Ditch the genres and start making your own music. See how far you can go with what you’ve learned.

10 Likes

Write a song about it.
Pour out all the dark and disturbing lust your soul has for new gear in pursuit of unobtainable rhythms and melodies.
It’ll be a massive hit. Everyone here can relate :woozy_face:

3 Likes

I just completely fundamentally disagree about music being cut and dry in this way…

The best music in any genre still has a magical component to it, you know it when you hear it, and it can’t be analyzed via a simple description or copied by applying the same gear or techniques. Chasing that magical feeling of things coming together is what makes music-making a never-ending journey that never stops being satisfying…

It’s possible your tastes have just changed and you don’t like the genres as much as you thought you did or used to, or that you, sorry to say, just don’t have the capacity to achieve that magic. Plenty of hobbyists don’t…

11 Likes

Wholly agree. This is the same reason I sold my AK recently. I just love playing with my hands. I love chords, harmony, and melody. That whole structure is so fun to explore.

I think you have it figured out, but why not apply those principles back to electronic stuff when you’re ready? Or, introduce electronic stuff slowly into your new workflow.

I recently got into digital synths again like wave sequencing. I love that they are highly polyphonic but also have this plastic like acoustic emulation sound to them.

Also, if you like piano, it’s hard not to play with prepared piano too. I was blown away at how fun and beautiful it can sound.

4 Likes

Let the wheels fall off and expectations fall away, including rules for what and how you should play and record.

Allow your own DIY recording regime to emerge which isn’t governed by any fixed rules.
Get weird, or not.

Do something musical each day, even if you’re not recording.

Give yourself permission to be 100% playful, 100% of the time.
See what happens.

(I’m not actually telling you to do this, just what I’ve found works for me after a long period of internal wrangling about what I should be doing musically. It now has a self-sustaining feel to it and it’s bloody wonderful)

6 Likes

There’s been a few threads like this lately…

Just breathe. Remember what attracted you in the first place. Stick to your guns. Try and set yourself some specific musical goals… “create a textural piece that explores x and y” “investigate percussive approaches lesser explored combined with z”. It is hard to offer specific advice without knowing your musical style…

The only other thing I would say is… don’t worry about it. Don’t force it. Leave it alone and the bug will eventually bite. Life is a long slow road. Enjoy it. And don’t be afraid of slowness and gaps and opportunities to explore other things.

Maybe avoid the whole influencer style thing if that’s something your doing, and focus on putting together more thoughtful compositions for a recording rather than things for online (again don’t know if u do that)

2 Likes

I somewhat agree , but I have experienced that sometimes the magic wears off quite quickly for me, and more quickly so in some genres than in others. So what I’m seeking is the magic that persists. For me, a lot of this is in the “classical” world – something like Bach cello suites or French impressionists kind of never wear off, and the more I understand them, the more fascinating they become.

But those are completely out of reach for playing myself. So for me as a hobbyist, I need to find a compromise between magic and feasibility.

2 Likes

I got bored of making tracks when I was tracking into a DAW.

Then I bought a Digitakt, dropped the DAW and started doing all my tracks live.

Much more satisfying.

14 Likes

On most traditional instruments, even an engaged amateur will never reach the level of mastery of an accomplished professional, yet this does not prevent most amateur musicians to both enjoy making music themselves and listening to others’ performances. I agree that there is something particular in electronic music making that might be related to the relative ease with which anyone can produce almost perfect sounds and conversely the difficulty of sensing futher progress after a couple of months with a new synth. Learning is much slower with traditional instruments, but the joy of sensing progress also lasts longer. I try to combine both - I have moments when I am focusing more (and sometimes rediscover) the synths and others where I find more joy with my acoustic instruments.

5 Likes

This is true I would agree. But you made me think that acoustic instruments are like, wonderful platforms for learning foundations of music. Bodily involvement - like on a drum kit. Your body grasps percussion and it sort of goes through you. But likewise learning harmony on one instruments sort of grants access on another. I personally know nothing about music theory and just go all on hearing and feeling.

But I do hear the OP’s probs. It happens to me all the time. Just can’t be arsed. I just stopped worrying about it. Go for a bike ride. Do yoga. Eat food. Have some beers with some mates. I’d rather be fully engaged or have a curiosity I’m pursuing than it being work. But I guess work is how you get stuff done.

3 Likes

Same. Real time is best.

6 Likes

I think you’ve made a really interesting and thoughtful post, and your point about satisfaction of creativity is important. For some people, there’s great enjoyment to be found in going deeper in the ‘cerebral’ process, working on more complex programming for instance, but it sounds like you’re wanting something more tactile.

There’s loads of electronic music that bridges production/sound design with instrumentalism - Herbie Hancock, Terry Riley and even Vangelis come to mind here. They’re often using effective ‘electronic music production’ processes, but are playing with a level of feeling and virtuosity more common in acoustic music (watch any of the billion covers of blade runner theme music on YouTube to see that Vangelis’s skill isn’t just in making the right patches).

And there are performers who aren’t tied to the keyboard - Suzanne Ciani’s Buchla stuff is living and breathing (and you don’t need a Buchla for this).

Obviously programmed and sequenced music dominates electronic genres, but there’s still a tonne of stuff that’s actively played. Maybe that’s where your middle ground lies?

5 Likes