I’m experiencing massively diminishing returns in music making – wiggling knobs is seriously less fun than it used to be.
I have (mostly, so far) avoided the temptation of throwing more gear at the problem, trying to find out the why instead. Obviously, all of this is completely subjective, but I’m wondering whether others here have been in a similar position, what you have done, and what you thoughts on the subject are.
(Warning, long-ish post.)
I think one of the problems is that, once you have the hang of it, it’s kind of easy to sound like 70% of the stuff out there, all of which kind of sounds the same (90% in the case of certain genres) – which is not a bad thing necessarily, it’s genre music after all. In the beginning I found this extremely satisfying – hey, I sound just like all the cool stuff I saw on Youtube! However, for me, this quickly flipped and turned into boredom. Which is strange - why can’t I simply enjoy making music, regardless of what and who it sounds like? I never had the intention to publish songs or make a living from music. As a hobbyist, I shouldn’t care less about the other stuff, so why does this feel demotivating?
The answer is, for me, not at all the other music out there in the end. I think it’s a lack of feeling authorship with electronic music. I don’t have to do anything really to make things sound cool. I don’t have to work on my tone, like the folks who play acoustic instruments. The guys at Moog or Korg or Sequential or Intellijel or Makenoise or … did that for me. And if it doesn’t work, there’s reverb and whatever granular effect is fancy these days. I’m just navigating between sweet spots thousands of others have explored before. (How many reviews of FX have you seen, where somebody uses phrases like “instant ambient machine”?) It’s a bit like taking photos in tourist hot spots. Go fancy with cool chords and key changes? Nah, adding Fmin maj7 add 13 over B# only sounds muddy on a complex waveform. Just throw an LFO at another parameter.
So, what to do?
One way out is to take on the producer challenge of making really really really good genre music, which probably means to invest a lot of time and money in really learning production, mastering, and the like. I’m guessing that this is the area that sets the top 30% of genre music apart from the rest, rather than the actual instruments, let alone musical sophistication. I admire people who are good at this, including so many on this forum, but I don’t want to go this route, because this inevitably means a more complex setup, more gear, and, worst of all, much more time on the computer, which is what I want to get away from by making music.
What I’m gravitating towards is something else: I have recently played around with my wife’s piano. While she plays Bach, Satie and Mendelsohn I’m struggling to find my way through simple chord progressions with inversions, but man this is so satisfying! If I want something to sound cooler, I cannot simply reach for another LFO or change the reverb algorithm. I have to find another chord inversion, add a 9th, change my rhythm, work on my left hand, etc. (Also, I’m quite blown away by the subtleties of even simple piano sounds, and the way that thing changes timbre over octaves. And it has 88 voice polyphony!) It’s super hard, and I’m pretty sure I’ll never sound good enough to share much of my music, but it’s so much fun just doing it. It has this feeling of I am making music. Or am I just excited from trying something new?
So, I’m pondering whether I sell all my synth gear or whether there is a middle ground. After all, I still love many of the sounds of analog subtractive synthesis. The Prophet 10 is temping, which was called the “piano synth” offering nothing to hide behind by another member of this forum. Other polys are tempting, too, or maybe a stage piano with a decent Rhodes?
Anyway, thanks for reading to anyone who made it till here. I’m quite curious to hear whether anyone of you has experienced something similar. And where you went from there.