Comments about your music

Ha ha ha! But only if you can be there and sample it. :stuck_out_tongue_winking_eye:

4 Likes

About 22 or so years ago, I had a personal website where I’d posted some recordings, mostly guitar-oriented stuff, and I had included an email address somewhere on the site. Someone took the time to send me an email saying, ā€œif I made music this bad, I would kill myself.ā€ This was pre social media, pre comments sections on websites – it actually took work to pass that little tidbit along. I’m embarrassed to say that I took everything down after that, and it was several years (and some major encouragement from my guitar teacher) before I posted anything publicly again. I wondered (and still do) if that came from someone with a burner email address who actually knew me, and knew me well enough to know I’d probably react the way I did. What’s interesting to me now is that, in spite of how much more toxic the internet has become overall since those days, things I’ve posted here or on YouTube have received some really great, positive, encouraging comments. Go figure.

7 Likes

I think that all of these insulting comments coming from people that can’t do shit themselves, a person who plays any instrument, producing music, does whatever knows that everyone start somewhere and how hard it is to climb up, they almost never will react with insults, they might throw in some constructive criticism but don’t think that they’ll go for these low insults…

I find them really funny because of how I think, I know that if that’s something shitty it’s probably coming from someone who’s opinion doesn’t worth shit.

8 Likes

When I’m happy I can read German :heart: :facepunch:!

1 Like

ā€œI don’t understandā€

Inspiring comment that keeps me going, even to this day

2 Likes

My conclusion after 20 years of being abused on the internet for existing is the following: There is no rhyme and no reason, no logic behind their comments, the just take whatever they can take to hurt one, and that’s what they get off on. Time is better spent making them feel unwelcome, instead of applaud them for appearing to have a half brain cell.

18 Likes

SAME> ENYA HOP hahah.

1 Like

haha :grin::handshake::grin:

1 Like

Someone messaged me recently on reddit to tell me my music sounds ā€œvideogamey.ā€ It was clearly meant as an insult, but… yeah, like half the music I listen to comes from video games and one of my goals as a musician is generally to capture the vibe of certain video games in my music. Thanks for stating the obvious, random internet weirdo :slight_smile:

5 Likes

Well, some of mine…

ā€œI can’t listen to this. This makes me aggressive.ā€

  • Friend walked in while I was starting a really chill out track with nothing really happening in there, yet.

ā€œI’m > good. I made it into 6 min.ā€

  • Same friend after listening to a cheesy hard trance track I made as a joke. Glad it didn’t make them aggressive this time.

ā€œYOU made this?ā€

  • Random friends.

ā€œI knew YOU made this.ā€

  • Former flatmate who probably knew me too well.

ā€œThat’s niceā€¦ā€ ā€œI really liked itā€¦ā€

  • Some folks on social, SC etc. I’m actually happy there are some people around the world who had a nice time with what I made.

ā€œā€¦ā€
Well?
ā€œWell, … ?ā€

  • Parents.
6 Likes

discovered that someone posted links to my stuff on some audiophiles forum and left me a review there, the genre I never knew I wanted, going to add this tag to all my stuff #hurlyburly

10 Likes

the soundcloud algorithm pushes my ambient tunes pretty hard, lots of listeners in russia and vietnam and occasionally brazil. they actually leave comments, i like this recent one

creepy

7 Likes

I woke up to a small comment on my latest tune and I don’t think I could ask for more really.

5 Likes

As long as people move to it, its all good

ā€œSick!ā€ is probably the most positive comment I heard someone say once… Can’t ask for much more can I

Recently sent an unfinished hip-hop track to a chat to ask for mixing advice, and one guy took an opportunity to say it sucks because it’s not hip-hop at all, it doesn’t follow the hip-hop conventions etc.
The thing is, the track is anything but original, it’s heavily inspired by a certain 2023 album, and people have told me it wouldn’t feel out of place on that album.
Also I’ve been told that it sounds professional, as in actually released music and not just someone’s sound doodles.

1 Like

This is possibly my favourite comment to a track so far, which translates as ā€˜babulal’, which apparently can have multiple meanings related to small children or bureaucracy. I named a song after it.

2 Likes

I first read this as babalu (rather than babulal) . Ha! Should probably get my glasses checked.

1 Like