A4 Feature Requests


#463

Sorry for the offtopic, but as you replied to my post about the subject I decided to reply to yours:

It’s not a consipiracy theory, it’s a fact. Even in your link the Elektron guy admits it possible but they have just decided not to implement it for now and claim it’s “really hard”. I bet if someone managed to get the source code for A4 OS, we would have an unofficial OS in a very short time period that includes MIDI sequencing.

That’s a silly excuse to not listen to your customers and add a feature that is requested the most.


#464

Elektron is a small company, spending time on A4 MIDI cuts into time elsewhere, I would guess that’s the biggest reason for not implementing it. There is a huge difference between what’s technically difficult and what is difficult in terms of man hours available.


#465

Yeah well in my opinion that sucks. MIDI sequencing is such a basic feature it should have been included from the start.


#466

If they wanted to limit a4 external midi sequencing for the sake of improving OT sales why would they release DT with this capability?


#467

A4 was released when OT was still in the middle of its life cycle. Now OT is quite old, they will probably retire it soon.


#468

We are all guessing, but my guess is they simply made a mistake in the design. The issue is specific to their analog units only. Seems they missed somthing in the hardware when developing and designing the analog units.

It would be nice if they could enable it but I bought them knowing they do not offer this functionality. So much gear out there does not midi sequence externally, we should just not assume all elektron gear will do so either. They were never sold with or promised these features in the analog boxes. As I said, would still love these features if they could include them.


#469

16 posts were merged into an existing topic: Off Topic Speculation


#479

Someone doesn’t show any knowledge on “how these things work”, unless they’re privy to the firmware and are an embedded/micro dev then they have no idea. Burden is on them to prove otherwise.


#480

Okay… so discussion about A4 MIDI sequencing feature request gets moved to “off topic speculation”. Why?


#481

They obviously don’t want to, for the reason that has been thrashed out on this forum so many times before. Whining about it is not going to make them include it. I bought an AK after doing my research, MIDI sequencing was not something I needed. If it’s something you do need, then don’t buy an A4/AK.

It’s this sense of entitlement that cracks me up. Company makes a car that clearly doesn’t fly. People buy car and complain that it doesn’t fly until they are blue in the face, and whine that the car is crippled because of it. Can’t you see the ridiculous side to this? :wink:


#482

This thread is about feature requests. Are we not allowed to discuss feature requests in this thread? Or are other feature requests allowed but MIDI sequencing should not be talked about?


#484

The topic is Feature Requests for the A4/k and discussion of those … unhelpful conspiracy speculation verging on trolling is not of interest to most who would like to follow the thread … it also won’t allow Elektron to easily browse through these suggestions when it’s derailed by such content

as you were :thup:


#485

Seconded! :thup:


#486

so maybe a new thread would be helpful… but to be honest the A4 is now an older tool, i don’t expect more development for the future


#487

I believe you mentioned it. How, on the A4, can I audition trigs w/locks?


#488

Hold the Trig (step rec mode obviously) then tap the lit note (if on the right octave, or shift)

Hacky but handy, presumably far easier on AK


#489

Excellent! Thank you!


#490

umm show me any car that can fly that i can buy
i can show you tens of boxes that can external seq you can buy.

your analogy cracks me up

ridiculous alright


#492

i still feel the analogy is a good one.


#493

Once I gave up on the idea that this instrument would ever be able to sequence MIDI, my time spent making music with it became much more enjoyable. I suggest you accept the fact that it cannot sequence MIDI, or sell it.